Search Link search
Home
About Us
  • District Attorney Stephanie L. Vettenburg-Shaffer
  • Duties and Responsibilities
  • Mission Statement
  • Our Team
  • The Criminal Justice System
  • Victim Services
Crime
  • Arrests
  • Cases
  • Most Wanted
  • Missing Persons
  • Warrants
    • Warrants - to be directed to McKean County Sheriff
Local Law Enforcement
Prevention & Awareness
  • Camera Registry
  • Community Resources
    • DA Anti-Drug Campaign
      • DA Shaffer and K9s at Local Events
      • DA Shaffer and PSP talk to Students
  • Drug Take Back
    • Drug Collection
Local Legal News
  • Appeals
    • Appeal of CW v Morrisroe
    • Appeal of CW v. Fuller
    • Appeal of CW v. Kelsey
    • Appeal of CW v. Perez
    • Appeal of CW v. Schoonover
    • Appeal of CW v. Yohe
  • Jury Trials
    • Jury Trial August 16, 2021
    • Jury Trial August 17 and 18, 2020
    • Jury Trial December 16, 2019
    • Jury Trial December 9, 2019
    • Jury Trial February 5-8, 2018
    • Jury Trial July 19 and 20, 2021
    • Jury Trial July 27, 2020
    • Jury Trial June 21 - June 24, 2021
    • Jury Trial May 18, 2021
    • Jury Trial October 12, 2021
    • Jury Trial October 13, 2021
    • Jury Trial October 18 and 19, 2021
    • Jury Trial October 21, 2019
    • Jury Trial October 27, 2020
    • Jury Trial October 28-31, 2019
    • Jury Trial September 1, 2020
    • Jury Trial of December 20, 2021
    • Jury Trial March 21 and 22, 2022
    • Jury Trial of January 3 and 4, 2022
    • Jury trial of March 14, 2022
Contact Us
  • Contact Info
  • Contact McKean County Drug Task Force
  • Contact Victim Witness Coordinator
  • General Contact Form
Events
  • K9s Visit Students
  • National Night Out 2021
  • National First Responders' Day
  • Veterans Day
  • Community Awareness Walk 2022
In Memoriam"I Support the Nose!" - Drug Awareness CampaignDetective K9 UnitJOB OPPORTUNITY IN LAW ENFORCEMENT
Recognition
  • DA RECOGNIZES CORRECTIONS' OFFICERS
FOLLOW
SUBMIT A TIP
  • Login Link LOGIN
  • Map Link CRIME MAP
McKean County DA
  • Address Link
  • Phone Link
  • Website Link
  • Facebook Link
District Attorney Stephanie L. Vettenburg-Shaffer
mckeanda.org
CRIMEWATCH / US / PA / McKean County
  • Login Link LOGIN
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • SUBMIT A TIP
McKean County District Attorney's Office Homepage
McKean County District Attorney's Office Logo

McKean County District Attorney's Office

District Attorney Stephanie L. Vettenburg-Shaffer
mckeanda.org
Search Link search Map Link CRIME MAP
  • Address Link
  • Phone Link
  • Website Link
  • Facebook Link
  • Home
  • About Us
    • District Attorney Stephanie L. Vettenburg-Shaffer
    • Duties and Responsibilities
    • Mission Statement
    • Our Team
    • The Criminal Justice System
    • Victim Services
  • Crime
    • Arrests
    • Cases
    • Most Wanted
    • Missing Persons
    • Warrants
      • Warrants - to be directed to McKean County Sheriff
  • Local Law Enforcement
  • Prevention & Awareness
    • Camera Registry
    • Community Resources
      • DA Anti-Drug Campaign
        • DA Shaffer and K9s at Local Events
        • DA Shaffer and PSP talk to Students
    • Drug Take Back
      • Drug Collection
  • Local Legal News
    • Appeals
      • Appeal of CW v Morrisroe
      • Appeal of CW v. Fuller
      • Appeal of CW v. Kelsey
      • Appeal of CW v. Perez
      • Appeal of CW v. Schoonover
      • Appeal of CW v. Yohe
    • Jury Trials
      • Jury Trial August 16, 2021
      • Jury Trial August 17 and 18, 2020
      • Jury Trial December 16, 2019
      • Jury Trial December 9, 2019
      • Jury Trial February 5-8, 2018
      • Jury Trial July 19 and 20, 2021
      • Jury Trial July 27, 2020
      • Jury Trial June 21 - June 24, 2021
      • Jury Trial May 18, 2021
      • Jury Trial October 12, 2021
      • Jury Trial October 13, 2021
      • Jury Trial October 18 and 19, 2021
      • Jury Trial October 21, 2019
      • Jury Trial October 27, 2020
      • Jury Trial October 28-31, 2019
      • Jury Trial September 1, 2020
      • Jury Trial of December 20, 2021
      • Jury Trial March 21 and 22, 2022
      • Jury Trial of January 3 and 4, 2022
      • Jury trial of March 14, 2022
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Info
    • Contact McKean County Drug Task Force
    • Contact Victim Witness Coordinator
    • General Contact Form
  • Events
    • K9s Visit Students
    • National Night Out 2021
    • National First Responders' Day
    • Veterans Day
    • Community Awareness Walk 2022
  • In Memoriam
  • "I Support the Nose!" - Drug Awareness Campaign
  • Detective K9 Unit
  • JOB OPPORTUNITY IN LAW ENFORCEMENT
  • Recognition
    • DA RECOGNIZES CORRECTIONS' OFFICERS

Want to Subscribe?

To follow McKean County District Attorney's Office, click the button below.


Download the CRIMEWATCH app and follow McKean County District Attorney's Office.

App StoreGoogle Play

buterbaugh_phot.jpg
fitz_photo.jpg
simmons_photo.jpg
shugars_photo.jpg

MCKEAN COUNTY DRUG TASK FORCE ARRESTS FOUR IN LATEST ARREST DETAIL 

(MCKEAN COUNTY, Pennsylvania: July 28, 2025): District Attorney Stephanie Vettenburg-Shaffer reports the results of an arrest detail involving 4 people in the county over the last five days which was the conclusion of a lengthy investigation into drug activity in the area. DA Vettenburg-Shaffer notes that drug investigations are ongoing and additional arrests are expected.

On Friday, July 25th, Task Force Detectives arrested Nateka SHUGARS, High Street, Bradford.  SHUGARS was charged with 2 counts of Delivery (Cocaine) (Felony); 2 counts of Possession (misdemeanors); and 2 counts of Criminal Use of a Communication Device (Felony 3). SHUGARS was arraigned by Magisterial District Judge Richard Luther who set bail at $250,000.  SHUGARS is scheduled for central court on July 31st. 

One day earlier, the Task Force Detectives charged another local woman with drug sales.  Katlyn BUTERBAUGH, of School Street, Bradford, was charged with 3 counts of Delivery of methamphetamine (Felony); 3 counts of Criminal Use of a Communication Facility (Felony 3); and 3 counts of Possession (Misdemeanor).  BUTERBAUGH is charged with delivering methamphetamine over the course of several months.  Court records note that a search warrant was executed at this residence following her arrest on Thursday.  BUTERBAUGH was arraigned by Magisterial District Judge Richard Luther who set bail at $200,000.  BUTERBAUGH is scheduled for central court on July 31st. 

Other persons arrested during this week’s arrest detail were Brian FITZPATRICK, of High Street, Bradford, and Guy SIMMONS, of West Corydon Street.  FITZPATRICK was charged with Delivery (crack cocaine) (Felony); Possession (misdemeanor); and Criminal Use of a Communication Facility .  FITZPATRICK was arraigned by Magisterial District Judge Richard Luther who set bail at $75,000.

Guy SIMMONS, of West Corydon Street, Bradford, was charged with Delivery (methamphetamine) (Felony); Conspiracy to Deliver (methamphetamine) (Felony); Possession (misdemeanor) and Paraphernalia (misdemeanor).  SIMMONS was  arraigned by Magisterial District Judge Richard Luther who set bail at $150,000.

Created Jul 28, 2025 @ 4:37 PM
buterbaugh_phot.jpg
fitz_photo.jpg
simmons_photo.jpg
shugars_photo.jpg
McKean County DA
500 W Main St
Smethport, PA 16749
EnglishEnglish
EnglishEnglishAmharicAmharicArabicArabicChinese (Simplified)Chinese (Simplified)Chinese (Traditional)Chinese (Traditional)DutchDutchFilipinoFilipinoFrenchFrenchGermanGermanHaitian CreoleHaitian CreoleHindiHindiItalianItalianJapaneseJapaneseKoreanKoreanPolishPolishPortuguesePortugueseRussianRussianSpanishSpanishSwahiliSwahiliVietnameseVietnamese
  • Contact McKean County DA
  • Compliance
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
IMPORTANT NOTIFICATION. Individuals accused of crimes and depicted on this and affiliate sites are presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Content on the CRIMEWATCH® platform and this website is posted, administered, and owned by law enforcement agencies, and is subject to change at any time. CRIMEWATCH Technologies, Inc., its owners, officers, directors, employees, agents, affiliates, and subsidiaries, provide NO WARRANTY OR REPRESENTATION regarding the contents of the CRIMEWATCH® platform or this website, and are not responsible for its accuracy, timeliness, or relevancy. For information about how to request the removal of inaccurate information, please go here.
CRIMEWATCH Technologies Homepage
CRIMEWATCH® and the Eye Design are registered trademarks of CRIMEWATCH Technologies, Inc. © 2025 CRIMEWATCH Technologies, Inc.

Want to Subscribe?

McKean County District Attorney's Office Badge

To subscribe to McKean County District Attorney's Office, click the button below.


Download the CRIMEWATCH app and follow McKean County District Attorney's Office.

App StoreGoogle Play